Byzantine, Texas

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

EU Court of Human Rights on Romanian Church "unions"

Posted on 5:52 PM by Unknown
(Economist) - When people believe they are ultimately working for God, do they have a right (like any other sort of worker) to organise themselves and demand fairer treatment from their earthly bosses? That is the one of the hardest questions at the interface of law and religion, because it involves a contest between two sorts of entitlement: the right of employees to band together and assert their interests, and the right of religious bodies to enforce their own rules.

An important ruling on this subject was handed down today. Not by the 28-member European Union (whose stance on religion I discussed in another recent posting - You really should read it. Big news in there.) but by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), which holds sway among 47 member nations of the Council of Europe and is supposed to be a guardian of civil liberties of all kinds. The verdict concerns a dispute between Romania's Orthodox Church, to which the great majority of people in that country adhere, and a 35-strong group of priests and other religious employees who tried, in 2008, to form a trade union. To the delight of conservative religious lobby groups, today's decision (accessible here in PDF form) upheld the church's point of view and said it was "not unreasonable" to have stopped the would-be union from establishing itself.

This marks the climax of a tortuous legal tale. Attempts to register the union (whose charter envisaged using "petitions, demonstrations and strikes as a means of defending its members' interests") were initially successful; then its registration was overturned by a national court. In January 2012 the ECHR found in favour of the embryonic union; but that decision was overturned today. A majority of judges found that in refusing to register the union, the Romanian state had legitimately "declined to become involved in the organisation and operation of the Romanian Orthodox Church." Given that church rules bar the formation of any clerical association without the bishop's approval, the state was simply showing an appropriate degree of neutrality and detachment with regard to the internal workings of the church.

That will be music to the ears of all those who campaign for the right of religious bodies to set their own rules and to enjoy exemptions, for example, from equality legislation which bars discrimination on grounds of gender or sexual orientation.

But look closely at the verdict, and it's not all good news for advocates of the autonomy of religious bodies. The judges did accept that in principle, at least, religious employees have entitlements under Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guarantees freedom of association. At the same time, they took into account the fact that Romania's church statutes do not provide for an "absolute ban" on the formation of trade unions; and in theory at least, the would-be union could have organised itself in ways that conformed to church rules.

The terms of today's decision leave it entirely possible that future rulings will go in favour of clerical and religious workers who want to form a union and are for some reason prevented from doing so. That will be some consolation for Unite, the British trade union which has a small division that offers advocacy and advice for Anglican clergy, even though it could hardly call them out on strike.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Bp. Vasilije of Tuzla and Zvornik and the sex scandal
    Bishop posing with Belgrade stripper Dejan Nestorovic Belgrade ( Radio Free Europe ) - The Serbian Orthodox Church has approved the resignat...
  • The Theophany of Our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ
    Theophany of our Lord, Troparion, Tone 1 When Thou, O Lord, wast baptized in the Jordan,/ the worship of the Trinity was made manifest;/ for...
  • “Let us at least die like Christians!”
    From the Archangel Gabriel Orthodox Church's website , a rather stirring story on Christian death from the book Everyday Saints . I can ...
  • Pseudo-Cyril of Alexandria on the Eucharist and the Godhead
    From the blog Roger Pearse , a post on how a modern opinion gets conflated with a patristic source. A correspondent has written to me with a...
  • Of Copts and unicorns - μονοκερωτων
    From the blog On Coptic Nationalism, a post entitled Coptic Unicorn: It's Symbolism . The very prominent Coptologist, Alin Siciu, has re...
  • Palm Sunday in Ottowa
  • Harry Potter: an Orthodoxy story?
    ( Moscow News ) - Harry Potter, the world’s most famous child sorceror, is to become an Orthodox Christian figure, in a play written by a pr...
  • Egyptian police abet rioting Muslims vs. mourning Christians
    Cairo ( AINA ) - A media representative for Egypt's Catholic bishops echoed concerns that police sided with Islamic extremists who attac...
  • OCN responds to sacrilegious SNL skit
    ( OCN ) - The Orthodox Christian Network has asked for a public apology from NBC for airing an offensive skit which depicted Jesus as a reve...
  • UK Copts want to accept Chalcedonians by confession
    ( British Orthodox ) - The Synod of the British Orthodox Church has submitted a recommendation to the Holy Synod of the Coptic Orthodox Patr...

Categories

  • books (2)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  August (47)
    • ▼  July (73)
      • Something to remember
      • More on the Esphigmenou monastery situation
      • "The Role of the Priest in the Parish in Secular S...
      • Assyrian Church of the East opens first parish in ...
      • Oriental Orthodox share in the joy of each others ...
      • Russian space center gets chaplain
      • Athonite monks fight eviction... with gasoline gre...
      • St. Tikhon’s Seminary has new dean
      • "Streaming the Ancient Faith" - Wesley J. Smith
      • Local Orthodox Churches reps. assembled for Baptis...
      • World Orthodoxy converges on Grand Kremlin Palace
      • Met. Hilarion: the West is trending towards dictat...
      • An intriguing discussion on contemporary monasticism
      • "The Garments of Salvation" now available from SVS...
      • Orthodoxy converging on Moscow to celebrate Baptis...
      • The Redemption of Bathsheba before the beautiful g...
      • A stirring Our Father
      • OCA delegation visits with Pat. Kirill of Moscow
      • Fr. Bruno Maggioni: the Italian singing, dancing p...
      • Arab Spring threatens to destroy priceless library
      • Serbian Patriarch Irinej meets with Patriarch Kiri...
      • I will greatly praise the Lord with my mouth...
      • Sonoma State apologizes for forced cross removals
      • St. Andrew's cross in Odintsovo
      • Bp. Gregory (ACROD) new Assembly of Bishops' OCF l...
      • Video game wipes out Pussy Riot invasions
      • Letter from Met. Hilarion to Western Rite communities
      • OCA to be at Baptism of Rus’ 1025th anniversary event
      • Patriarch Irinej of Serbia visiting Russia
      • A Russian response to an exclusively Hellenic Sout...
      • Autocephaly problem: history and present
      • New Pope of Rome to visit Constantinople
      • Of beer and Texas
      • Copts lodge complaint against Egyptian constitution
      • The Church in Belarus: more equal than others?
      • Oremus blog on ROCOR's Western Rite announcement
      • Big news for the Western Rite, ROCOR, and Bp. Jerome
      • The Russian Church in Bethany meets Muslim resistance
      • Bp. Michael of NY visits Russian metochion
      • EU Court of Human Rights on Romanian Church "unions"
      • Maronites in US get new bishop
      • SVOTS dean Fr. John Behr visits Egypt
      • Cross of St. Andrew tours Russia, Ukraine, and Bel...
      • California doctors pressure female inmates into st...
      • Bulgarian Metropolitan Kiril of Varna has reposed
      • The Orthodox Children’s Press
      • Oriental Orthodox, Assyrian Church of the East mee...
      • On Georgia's Davit Gareja monastery
      • On dog-faced St. Christopher
      • Straight talk on the Bible
      • Being a priest's wife isn't easy
      • Welsh welshing on organ rights
      • Cowards shoot Coptic priest in the street
      • Met. Nektarios of HK speaks again on Taipei church...
      • Show trial sentences Abp. Jovan of Ohrid to 3 year...
      • A new missionary for Fiji
      • St. George Church fundraises for displaced Syrian ...
      • Episcopal Assembly of Oceania commemorates Edict o...
      • The BBC on the Georgian Church
      • A history of the readings in the Divine Liturgy
      • New Antiochian Convent of St. Thekla grounds blessed
      • Pro-abortion activists chant "God is dead" and "Ha...
      • Working with orphans in Ukraine
      • Notes from this year's Orientale Lumen Conference
      • Post-USSR Moldova struggles with Church-State rela...
      • Pick-a-priest in the Diocese of Eastern PA
      • Met. Tikhon visits San Francisco
      • Show trial against Abp. Jovan of Ohrid has ended
      • Assyrian Church of the East meets in Austria
      • "There Is No Sex in the Church!"
      • On the violence of the Old Testament
      • Inter-parliamentary Assembly of Orthodoxy in Athens
      • Ordination to the diaconate
    • ►  June (51)
    • ►  May (95)
    • ►  April (71)
    • ►  March (63)
    • ►  February (56)
    • ►  January (44)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile