Byzantine, Texas

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Is rejection of same-sex relationships Orthodox?

Posted on 9:49 AM by Unknown
From the blog Mysterion, the first in a multi-part series on the question "How do we know that the rejection of same-sex relationships is Orthodox?"


The following is part of a correspondence with a friend of mine, who asked that I refer to him by his baptismal name: Basil. The question originally asked was, "How do we know that the rejection of same-sex relationships is Orthodox?" I hope to publish further portions of my responses in the next few weeks.

Dear Basil:

I apologize in advance for the length of this email. I also apologize for the time it has taken me to respond to your original email. I delayed for a couple of reasons. First and most obviously, the questions you asked are significant and deserved a measure of consideration before I could offer a suitable response. Second, I cannot escape the feeling that the standard responses to these questions, which we typically see in a wide variety of Orthodox apologetic literature—sermons, articles, podcasts, books, retreats, and even hierarchical epistles—are somehow threadbare and inadequate, if not for Orthodox insiders, then certainly for the people of our generation outside the Church to whom we are trying to give an answer for the hope that lies within us.

If our audience lay within the Church, or if this were another time in history, I might find a response easier. If you asked at that time, “How do we know that the rejection of same-sex relationships is Orthodox?” I might first appeal to custom and say that the Orthodox Church rejects same-sex relationships because it has always done so. This answer may well satisfy the insiders; in a more conservative time, it may also have satisfied non-Christians who valued conformity, duty and honour to a given cultural tradition. However, our contemporary society, particularly in the West but rapidly on a global level, no longer upholds such values. Perhaps we have witnessed too many historical instances in which cultural conformity, duty and honour have produced nothing but violence, death and destruction. Even as an Orthodox Christian, I see some of my fellow Orthodox devoting themselves to slavish obedience over practices and teachings that are trivial at best and destructive at worst. Even if I were to appeal to custom in answering your question, I might well be reminded of the words of St. Cyprian of Carthage, “Custom without truth is merely the antiquity of error.”

Perhaps I might appeal to Scripture and the teachings of the Fathers to bolster my argument from custom. I could point to the various verses that you mentioned in your first email, the strictures (supposedly against same-sex relationships) from the Old and New Testaments. I might dredge the sayings and writings of the Fathers for quotes that supported the ongoing practice of the Church. Again, if you were already convinced of the matter, no doubt this scriptural and patristic evidence would suffice. If you spent some time considering these texts, though, you might find yourself increasingly troubled. In your first email, you correctly pointed out the problems involved with using scriptural verses to legislate on our contemporary situation. Scriptural proof-texting, even at its most sophisticated, is not sufficiently compelling to a postmodern generation that tends to be suspicious of any attempt to assign texts of any sort, let alone Scripture, with inherent objective authority. To put it simply, if I were to answer your question, “How do we know…?” by saying, “Because it is in the Book,” you might be convinced, but no one else would be...

Complete post here.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Bp. Vasilije of Tuzla and Zvornik and the sex scandal
    Bishop posing with Belgrade stripper Dejan Nestorovic Belgrade ( Radio Free Europe ) - The Serbian Orthodox Church has approved the resignat...
  • The Theophany of Our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ
    Theophany of our Lord, Troparion, Tone 1 When Thou, O Lord, wast baptized in the Jordan,/ the worship of the Trinity was made manifest;/ for...
  • “Let us at least die like Christians!”
    From the Archangel Gabriel Orthodox Church's website , a rather stirring story on Christian death from the book Everyday Saints . I can ...
  • Pseudo-Cyril of Alexandria on the Eucharist and the Godhead
    From the blog Roger Pearse , a post on how a modern opinion gets conflated with a patristic source. A correspondent has written to me with a...
  • Of Copts and unicorns - μονοκερωτων
    From the blog On Coptic Nationalism, a post entitled Coptic Unicorn: It's Symbolism . The very prominent Coptologist, Alin Siciu, has re...
  • Palm Sunday in Ottowa
  • Harry Potter: an Orthodoxy story?
    ( Moscow News ) - Harry Potter, the world’s most famous child sorceror, is to become an Orthodox Christian figure, in a play written by a pr...
  • Egyptian police abet rioting Muslims vs. mourning Christians
    Cairo ( AINA ) - A media representative for Egypt's Catholic bishops echoed concerns that police sided with Islamic extremists who attac...
  • OCN responds to sacrilegious SNL skit
    ( OCN ) - The Orthodox Christian Network has asked for a public apology from NBC for airing an offensive skit which depicted Jesus as a reve...
  • UK Copts want to accept Chalcedonians by confession
    ( British Orthodox ) - The Synod of the British Orthodox Church has submitted a recommendation to the Holy Synod of the Coptic Orthodox Patr...

Categories

  • books (2)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  August (47)
    • ►  July (73)
    • ►  June (51)
    • ►  May (95)
    • ►  April (71)
    • ▼  March (63)
      • How it should be done: St. Innocent Church in Maco...
      • St. Philotheus and the Sunday of St. Gregory Palamas
      • The whys on dating Pascha
      • OCMC in "urgent" need of your help
      • Met. Tikhon, OCA Council provide update on Met. Jonah
      • Yale - Lux et veritas.
      • Watertown, MA church robbed
      • Parousia when?
      • On the Assembly of Bishops Committee for Youth
      • Death of the branch theory
      • Man wants to remarry, gets govt. involved
      • Curtains and the Presanctified Liturgy
      • Prayer, fasting, and almsgiving.
      • Liturgy of the Presanctified Gifts in Moscow
      • Iconodules the new iconoclasts?
      • Met. Tikhon at Sunday of Orthodoxy service in DC
      • Pan-Orthodox Vespers, the American experience
      • Holy Cross Monastery - a story of survival
      • President Barack Obama visits Church of the Nativity
      • Met. Tikhon welcomed at Rome’s Russian Orthodox Ch...
      • EP invites Pope to travel with him to Holy Land
      • Reading The Scriptures in an Orthodox Manner
      • Cypriot Church in the trenches with government
      • Pope of Rome to Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, et al.
      • Chalcedon 28 - controversial barbarian lands
      • Update on internecine discord in Ukraine
      • Orientale Lumen Conferences scheduled
      • Orthodox delegations in Rome for papal inauguratio...
      • The UK: canary in the coal mine.
      • A video on the bright line of division
      • Kristen Stewart explains St. Patrick's Day
      • Ten Lenten tips
      • Who’s Who of The Great Canon of St. Andrew of Crete
      • Notes from OCA synodal spring session
      • Want some Lenten resources?
      • School of Liturgical Chant launched in Chicago
      • Ecumenical Patriarch to attend papal inaugural mass
      • Is rejection of same-sex relationships Orthodox?
      • Antioch and Jerusalem at odds over Qatar
      • The Two Chairs of Peter
      • On papal fervor
      • Pithless Thoughts responds to OCN's SNL appeal
      • OCN responds to sacrilegious SNL skit
      • First Maronite elector ever for Pope of Rome
      • "How Medicine is Destroying Pastoral Care"
      • Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew on the Great Fast
      • Oriental Orthodox respond to John X of Antioch's o...
      • The Copts in Jerusalem
      • Want to see how un-Christlike you are? Try raising...
      • The Last Judgement
      • Jurisdictional webmasters meet at St. Vlad's
      • On Orthodoxy and a new Pope of Rome
      • Things Jesus never said
      • OCF: Making a difference in New Orleans
      • Moscow Times: The Interior of a Church
      • This video makes me uncomfortable
      • On the Ancient of Days icon
      • “Let us at least die like Christians!”
      • St. Emmelia Orthodox Homeschooling Conference
      • Flowers continue to bloom in Arab Spring
      • Resurrection of our Lord Chapel in Dachau Camp
      • "A Journey of Faith" - Growing the Church in Kenya
      • Pastor and laity - "Blurred Lines"
    • ►  February (56)
    • ►  January (44)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile